ACL Surgery, Graft Options and Rehabilitation: Courtney’s Story of True Grit

By Daniel Rothenberg, Sports Chiropractor and Strength & Conditioning Coach, Scope Sports Injury & Exercise Clinic, East Ipswich

Getting back to soccer after an ACL injury was always Courtney’s goal. What she hadn’t expected was how much of her recovery would involve working patiently towards smaller milestones first.

The Ipswich FC player and electrical apprentice faced significant knee pain, ACL reconstruction, persistent stiffness and a further procedure to improve movement. Progress often felt slow, even when she was consistently doing the work.

In our Back 2 Your Best Rehab Podcast conversation, Courtney shared what helped her keep going over approximately 18 months: achievable goals, support from those around her and learning to recognise progress that wasn’t always obvious.

Her experience is also an opportunity to explain some of the decisions people face after an ACL injury, from surgery and graft choices to rehabilitation and return-to-running preparation.

An injury that interrupted sport, work and everyday life

Courtney was playing soccer when a shoulder-to-shoulder contest ended with her on the ground. She heard a crack and realised she couldn’t get up.

An X-ray ruled out a fracture. With ongoing swelling and difficulty bearing weight, she later had an MRI that confirmed an ACL injury.

When we first met, her knee was extremely painful and difficult to move. Returning to the soccer field felt distant, and her injury also meant moving away from on-site duties during her electrical apprenticeship.

The initial plan, developed alongside her surgeon, was to improve movement and settle the knee before surgery. She made some gains, but bending and straightening remained challenging. She eventually underwent ACL reconstruction and treatment to her meniscus.

Does every ACL injury need surgery?

An ACL tear needs an individual assessment and a rehabilitation plan. The decision about surgery considers whether the knee gives way, the demands of work and sport, associated injuries and the person’s goals.

Some people can manage with structured rehabilitation, particularly if their knee is functionally stable and their activities do not involve frequent cutting or pivoting. Others consider reconstruction because of ongoing instability or a goal of returning to demanding pivoting sports such as soccer. Meniscus injuries and damage to other ligaments can also influence the recommendation. [1]

A useful discussion with your surgeon and rehabilitation clinician should cover the options available, their risks and benefits, and the work involved in recovery. Both surgical and non-surgical pathways require rehabilitation.

ACL reconstruction, repair and additional procedures

ACL reconstruction replaces the torn ligament with a tendon graft. It is the established surgical approach for many ACL tears. ACL repair aims to preserve and reattach the injured ligament and may be considered for selected tear patterns; suitability depends on factors such as tear location and tissue quality. Repair is not interchangeable with reconstruction for every injury. [1,2]

Some patients may also be offered an additional stabilising procedure, such as a lateral extra-articular tenodesis, to support rotational stability. This is a consideration for selected higher-risk situations rather than a routine requirement for everyone. [2]

The operation needs to reflect the whole knee injury. A meniscus repair, for example, can change early movement and loading precautions. Ask your surgeon exactly what was treated and what restrictions apply to your recovery. [1]

ACL graft types: what are the main considerations?

An autograft uses your own tendon tissue. An allograft uses donor tissue. Common autograft options include patellar, hamstring and quadriceps tendon. Each has trade-offs, including symptoms or weakness at the harvest site. [1]

Graft optionWhat it involvesPoints to discuss with your surgeonPatellar tendon autograftUsually a strip of tendon with a bone block at each end.An established option. AAOS guidance recognises potential advantages for graft-failure risk compared with hamstring grafts in some circumstances, balanced against more front-of-knee or kneeling pain.Hamstring tendon autograftTissue from one or more hamstring tendons.May reduce kneeling discomfort compared with patellar tendon harvest. Rehabilitation also needs to address hamstring strength and function after harvest.Quadriceps tendon autograftA portion of the tendon above the kneecap, with or without a bone block.Another autograft option. Harvest-site symptoms and quadriceps strength recovery are important rehabilitation considerations.Donor tendon allograftTendon from a tissue donor.Avoids harvesting your own tendon, but AAOS recommends favouring autograft particularly in young or active people because of graft-failure considerations.

Graft selection considers activity demands, age, previous surgery, available tissue, surgeon experience and work requirements such as frequent kneeling. There is no single choice that suits every person. AAOS guidance and research on muscle recovery help inform these trade-offs, but do not replace an individual surgical discussion. [2,5]

Courtney’s interview did not identify her graft type. The options above provide general background rather than details of her operation.

When recovery needed another procedure

At her six-week postoperative review, Courtney still struggled to bend her knee beyond approximately 90 degrees. Her surgeon identified scar tissue as a contributing factor and recommended a manipulation under anaesthetic to help restore movement.

She felt the procedure helped, but it introduced another challenge into her recovery. Persistent stiffness sometimes requires further surgical assessment or treatment after ACL reconstruction. [1]

Courtney also learned that working harder could not simply force her knee to recover faster. Her plan needed consistent effort, review and adjustment according to her progress.

What does ACL rehabilitation generally look like?

Rehabilitation progresses from restoring knee function to building the capacity required for work, running and sport. The following stages are approximate guides after reconstruction. Graft choice, additional procedures, symptoms and complications can change the plan. [3,4]

Approximate stageMain goalsBefore surgery, where appropriateImprove movement, quadriceps function and understanding of the recovery plan.First 0–6 weeksManage swelling, restore knee extension and progressively improve bending, muscle activation and walking within postoperative precautions.Around 6–12 weeksBuild strength, movement control and tolerance for daily activity.From approximately 3–4 months, when readyProgress impact preparation and introduce graded running if clinical and functional criteria are met. Some people require substantially longer.Later rehabilitationDevelop jumping, landing, faster running, deceleration and change-of-direction capacity, followed by sport-specific training.Around 9–12 months or longerConsider progression towards pivoting or contact sport based on healing time, testing, training tolerance and psychological readiness.

These stages overlap, and the calendar alone does not establish readiness. Courtney’s recovery took longer than she had hoped; her experience illustrates why plans need room for individual variation.

Returning to running is a milestone, not the finish line

For Courtney, running again was one of the most meaningful steps in her recovery. She had missed it for well over a year.

At the time of recording, she had also started playing six-a-side soccer, while continuing to learn how much activity her knee could tolerate. Her goal was to regain the ability to choose whether to play, rather than feel that the injury had made that choice for her.

The Aspetar guideline proposes assessing movement, swelling, quadriceps strength and impact tolerance when considering return to running. These suggested criteria combine available evidence with expert opinion and require clinical interpretation. [3]

Our return-to-run approach connects gym-based rehabilitation with gradually increasing running demands. Later preparation may include acceleration, braking, changing direction and responding to sport-specific situations. Being able to jog is an important achievement, with further preparation required for soccer.

Small wins and a supportive environment

Courtney trained at the rehab gym two or three times a week and completed prescribed work at home. During difficult periods, returning to on-site work gave her an achievable goal closer than a full return to soccer.

She found encouragement in comments from coaches and other members who noticed improvements she had missed. Reflecting on the journey, she also wished she had spoken more openly about the emotional challenges earlier.

Her story of grit includes all of those elements: persistence, adjusting expectations and allowing others to support her along the way.

Specialised ACL rehab in Ipswich with Back 2 Your Best

Our Back 2 Your Best Rehab Program supports people through surgical and non-surgical ACL rehabilitation, from early recovery to return-to-running and sport preparation.

Based at Scope Sports Injury & Exercise Clinic, 5 Jacaranda Street, East Ipswich, our approach combines:

  • Individualised whole-body programming to rebuild your knee and wider strength and physical capacity.

  • Expert rehab coaching to guide technique, exercise selection and progressive loading.

  • Clinical appointments and hands-on treatment where appropriate, coordinated with your rehabilitation plan and surgical precautions.

  • Regular strength and functional testing to help assess progress and guide next steps.

  • Structured return-to-run training to build impact tolerance and progressively develop running capacity.

  • Field-based rehabilitation progressing towards acceleration, deceleration, change of direction and sport-specific demands when appropriate.

Your Back 2 Your Best membership brings programming, coached sessions, clinical appointments, progress testing and rehab gym access together under one roof. You have a consistent place to train, ask questions and have your plan adjusted as your recovery develops.

Whether you are weighing up treatment options, preparing for surgery or struggling to progress towards running and sport, we can assess your starting point and discuss a plan around your goals.

Explore the Back 2 Your Best ACL rehab program and membership options.

References

  1. American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons. ACL Injury: Does It Require Surgery? https://www.orthoinfo.org/bodypart/kneelower-leg/acl-injury-does-it-require-surgery/

  2. AAOS. Management of Anterior Cruciate Ligament Injuries: guideline update. https://www.aaos.org/aaos-home/newsroom/press-releases/aaos-updates-guideline-for-management-of-acl-injuries/

  3. Aspetar. Clinical Practice Guideline on Rehabilitation after ACL Reconstruction. https://aspetar.com/en/professionals/aspetar-clinical-guidelines/recommendations-on-rehabilitation-after-aclr

  4. NHS Fife. Anterior Cruciate Ligament Surgical Reconstruction. https://www.nhsfife.org/services/all-services/patient-advice/anterior-cruciate-ligament-acl-surgical-reconstruction/

  5. Holmgren D, et al. Weaker Quadriceps Muscle Strength With a Quadriceps Tendon Graft Compared With a Patellar or Hamstring Tendon Graft at 7 Months After Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38164665/

Previous
Previous

Nat’s ACL Rehab: Rebuilding Strength, Explosiveness and Confidence for Squash

Next
Next

Shoulder Reconstruction and Rehabilitation: Leah’s Story of Rebuilding Confidence